Thomas More
1478 CE – 1535 CE · Renaissance Era
“An ideal society requires communal property, religious tolerance, and universal education.”
Biography
Sir Thomas More was a lawyer, statesman, and Lord Chancellor of England who coined the word 'utopia', literally 'no place.' His Utopia imagines an ideal society that critiques the injustices of Tudor England. He was executed for refusing to accept Henry VIII as head of the Church of England.
Major Works
Key Arguments
Click “Philosophy 101” to read the full exploration of each argument.
The Utopian Critique of Private Property
More's Utopia describes an island society where private property has been abolished: all goods are held in common, all citizens work six hours a day, and no one suffers want while others live in luxury. The fictional traveler Raphael Hythloday argues that as long as private property exists, the wealth of nations will be distributed to the worst people and the majority will live in misery. England's enclosure of common lands was driving peasants from their homes so that the rich could raise sheep, 'your sheep,' Hythloday says, 'that used to be so meek and eat so little, have become so greedy and wild that they devour the men themselves.' In Utopia, by contrast, the abolition of money and private ownership removes the motives for crime, corruption, and exploitation.
Why it matters: Utopia (1516) inaugurated the modern tradition of imagining boldly different social arrangements as a way of criticizing existing ones. The book directly influenced later socialist and communist thought, Marx and Engels acknowledged More as a precursor, and established the genre of utopian fiction that runs through Campanella, Bacon, and on to modern science fiction. The word 'utopia' itself, meaning both 'good place' (eu-topos) and 'no place' (ou-topos), captures the permanent ambiguity of the enterprise.
The Ambiguity of Utopia: Irony as Philosophical Method
More's genius is that Utopia resists any simple reading. More himself appears as a character who expresses doubts about Hythloday's proposals. The Utopians practice religious tolerance, but also slavery. They disdain gold, but use it for chamber pots and prisoners' chains. The narrator's name, Hythloday, means 'speaker of nonsense' in Greek. Is More seriously advocating communism, or satirizing it? Is Utopia a blueprint or a thought experiment? The most sophisticated reading holds both possibilities in tension: More uses the device of an imaginary society to expose the injustices of his own world while simultaneously acknowledging that perfect societies may be impossible, that 'utopia' is, by definition, 'no place.'
Why it matters: More pioneered the use of systematic ambiguity as a philosophical method. By refusing to tell readers what to think, by constructing a text that can be read as both bold critique and ironic comedy, he forced readers to think for themselves about justice, property, and the limits of social reform. This technique influenced the entire tradition of philosophical fiction, from Swift's Gulliver's Travels through Huxley's Brave New World to Le Guin's The Dispossessed.
Conscience Against the State
When Henry VIII broke with Rome and demanded that his subjects swear an oath acknowledging him as Supreme Head of the Church of England, More, who had served as Lord Chancellor, the highest legal officer in the realm, refused. He did not publicly condemn the king's actions; he simply remained silent, believing his silence could not legally be construed as treason. He was wrong: his silence was taken as refusal, and he was tried, convicted, and beheaded in 1535. On the scaffold, he declared himself 'the King's good servant, but God's first.' More's martyrdom enacted the principle that individual conscience has a higher authority than the commands of the state, that there are things a person cannot do regardless of what the law demands.
Why it matters: More's execution became a defining act of principled resistance. His stand established the claim, later central to theories of civil disobedience, conscientious objection, and human rights, that the individual conscience is sovereign over political authority. He was canonized by the Catholic Church in 1935 and declared the patron saint of statesmen and politicians by Pope John Paul II.
Lasting Influence
Coined 'utopia.' Influenced socialist thought and the tradition of ideal society theorizing. The irony of the text is that Utopia's own design -- total surveillance, assigned labor, no private property -- anticipates the authoritarian logic of every regime that has tried to implement its premises. More may have seen this, which is why the names are jokes. His readers should too.
Your Reading Path
The Companion Guide
Seven eras of philosophy in one volume — reading lists, key terms, journal prompts · $19.99